(Reposted from State of the Street, with permission)
Brian Packham as back on Coronation Street and many fans are rejoicing. For me, it's a mixed bag of joy and dread. You see, I never liked Brian. He's a buffoon. He's selfish, greedy and boorish. He's an intellectual snob, even more so than Ken Barlow. One scene that stands out in my mind was Brian, staying at Ken's, helped himself to Ken's kimono without asking. It never seemed to occur to him that he should have. Borrowing a shirt or a jumper would have been bad enough, but a dressing gown is a rather intimate garment and it made me cringe with disgust that he would think nothing of rooting through Ken's closet or laundry and doing it.
This week, we saw him apparently investigating the Bistro for Environmental Health but in reality, was just after a free meal. Never mind that the complaint would have been logged and his superiors would be looking for a proper report. Never mind that not only was he angling for a free meal, he managed to down THREE bowls of mussels. I'm surprised he didn't insist Robert hand him cash to get out of the investigation. If I was Robert, I'd be reporting him.
Brian is very much cut from a similar cloth to Derek Wilton and I never liked him either.
Both men had a nicer side, a softer side. They both loved and were loved. Derek and Mavis were soul mates even though he exasperated her many times (and probably, vice versa!). Julie and Brian seemed like a good couple and were very much in love but apparently, they did not go the distance. Soul mates they weren't in the end. Both men were a bit hapless and not very good at what they did in spite of them both thinking quite highly of themselves and their abilities.
Another current character I never liked is Norris Cole who's a sanctimonious, gossipy and at times thoroughly nasty little man. He, too, can pull his heart out of the cold storage now and then and be kind to someone when you least expect it but for the most part, I don't know why he has any friends at all. When he was first on the show in the 90s he was a spiteful and arrogant piece of work. He's softened a little in his old age but he still has his backside firmly on that high horse.
The fourth current character that evokes a strong negative response in me is Pat Phelan. There is very little soft side to him, and I think there's a stone swinging in his chest where his heart should be. He's opportunistic, greedy, ambitious, controlling and he's a bully. He's a classic Corrie villain.
I would describe my feelings for Brian, Derek and Norris as "I really don't like them". But I very much enjoy Pat Phelan as a character. I really enjoy watching him. He's so bad, he's good! I don't know what the difference is unless it's the villain aspect. Villains are always more interesting.
The thing is, I like/liked to hate all four characters. This comes down to two things. The writing is usually great and the actors themselves are highly skilled. I think all four men put in top performances and that contributes to the "like to hate" syndrome. I have to admit, Norris is a bit of a struggle at times and I don't find him as funny as most people I know (though he does get in a great line now and then) but Brian and Derek can always make me laugh and Pat Phelan keeps me glued to the screen. (going with the present tense here, even though Derek Wilton and his portrayer are no longer with us) The actors all have impeccable timing whether it's for comedy or drama.
There have been a lot of characters over the years that I've not liked much. What brings a viewer to like or dislike a character, and note, I said "character" not "actor", is generally subjective. The character is usually written specifically *to* be dislikeable or to have dislikeable characteristics but the viewer doesn't always agree. What one person finds dislikeable about, say, Brian Packham, someone else will find funny or intriguing.
Other "love to hate" characters over the years have included Cilla Battersby Brown, Nessa, Reg Holdsworth, Nick Tilsley and Tracy Barlow. I confess I really disliked Kate Ford in her first few years playing Tracy, but she's settled in and come a long way. The perceived skill of the actor makes a huge difference for me in whether I like to dislike a character or whether I really, really find them off-putting. There have been many over the years that I felt couldn't act their way out of a paper bag but I'm going to refrain from naming names.
Characters that you like to hate are usually interesting, intriguing, sometimes funny, sometimes tragic, sometimes both. Maybe they're a bit exaggerated but others might be very understated. I think that once an actor proves their acting chops and makes a character their own, the writers can really play to their strengths which makes them so much more watchable. Apparently, the writing team had a ball writing for Maggie Jones who played Blanche Hunt due to her amazing delivery of those acerbic lines we all remember.
The writing and acting skill really do combine to make a character great, whether it be a hateful piece of work, a comedy stalwart, or an adored sweetheart of the Street. When the character is all over the place, when their personalities are unfathomably transplanted, when it seems like the writers and producers don't know what to do with them, they stop being watchable and enter that dreaded realm of the forgettable. (Katie Armstrong, anyone?)
I'm all for Love to Hate characters that give us the comedy gold or the tension that has us on the edge of our seats. Kudos to the subperb actors behind the facades who bring the characters to life, creating the unforgettable.
Tvor (Twitter @tvordlj)
Like us on Facebook | Follow us on Twitter | Download our free App | Visit Corrie.net
NEW!
Coronation Street: The Official Colouring Book
Available now!
Please read our advice for leaving comments on the Coronation Street Blog
All original work on the Coronation Street Blog is covered by a Creative Commons License
Wednesday 23 November 2016
Characters I "Love to Hate"
Labels:
brian packham,
characters,
derek wilton,
newsnow,
norris cole,
pat phelan
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
You might also like...
-
Friday 19th April 2024 DANIEL HANDS MAX A SMOKING GUN Bethany does her best to persuade Daniel to put thoughts of Lauren to the back of his ...
-
Here are the major storylines for the week ahead on Coronation Street, all wrapped up nicely in 50 words or less. Monday 29 April to Friday ...
-
Wednesday 24th April 2024 TOYAH’S SECRET IS REVEALED Nick desperately tries to keep the peace between Leanne and Toyah. When Joel asks Leann...
-
Monday 22nd April 2024 TOYAH SEES RED ON THE REC Leanne facetimes Rowan to tell him about Toyah’s negativity towards the Institute and Rowan...
-
Apologies for absence last Friday - I was off to Bari on Saturday and ran out of time. Tonight in Weatherfield Nick looks continually perpl...
-
So first of all, the week starts with Paul appearing on Amy's radio show. How does that all go for him? Yes, that's quite an inte...
-
Why do you think Bobby was so suspicious of Roy in the beginning? It was that thing of Bobby being new to the street and outwardly Roy has...
-
Here are the major storylines for the week ahead on Coronation Street, all wrapped up nicely in 50 words or less. Monday 22 April to Friday ...
-
Wednesday 17th April 2024 DANIEL’S OLD JACKET ATTRACTS SOME FUZZ Bobby’s face pales as he receives a call summoning him to the station for f...
-
Roy Cropper is innocent - it says so on this fab t-shirt sent to me from ITV. But don't just take my word for it, hear what Carla has...
6 comments:
TVOR, I loved your blog and agree wholeheartedly with all your love to hate characters! Am a Canadian viewer so haven't seen Brian's reappearance yet but am not looking forward to it. I have never liked Brian either thought he was a pompous ass and didn't think he treated Julie very well at all.
As for scamming for a free meal off Robert ridiculous. Anyone with half a brain would know a Health Inspector would be checking the kitchen for infractions not wolfing down food. Robert should have called the police - he is an experienced chef he would certainly know better. Sloppy writing for sure.
Brian is a pompous ass and everything else! But he's very watchable due to the wonderful actor and they must have a lot of fun writing for him.
Percy Sugdon comes to mind when I read this.
Agree about Norris, he is an odious busybody, I really don't like watching any scenes he is in.
What's good about Phelan is that he's actually a real villainous character, not someone from the comic-book line of villainy such as Caz, Callum, Vinny, Tracy, David on his bad days, and many others.
But even though he didn't directly kill him, in soap fashion he will pay for Michael's death down the line, probably with his own.
As I recall Norris' earliest incarnation, he wasn't so much vindictive as an naive, over-enthusiastic, irritating pest, who (weirdly) seemed to idolize Derek Wilton (Dirk!). He was also given to practical jokes (the Travelling Gnome saga) - VERY different from what he evolved into.
Post a Comment