Cross posted with permission from State of the Street.
With the latest rumours suggesting that Charlie Lawson may bring Big Jim McDonald back to Coronation Street, there are fans jumping for joy and other fans cringing. I'm one of the former. People accuse the character of Jim as being a "one trick pony", coming in to do the same things over and over. He'll try to get Liz back, she'll be tempted, he'll mess up, argue with Steve, probably do something stupid and leave. Lather, rinse, repeat.
And maybe it will go down like that, with lots of Jim's sayings to pepper the pot. "The Big House", "So it is", "I'll tell ye this and I'll tell ye no more", "Ach to be sure" and calling Liz "Elizabeth". It ought to be a drinking game! Fans of Jim squeal when one of his familiar sayings slips out. You feel let down if one's missing, in fact.
As far as being a one trick pony, when I look back, there are many, many characters that are just the same. Stan Ogden, anyone? (Drink, cower under Hilda's wrath, cook up schemes, evade work where possible. Repeat. And the same could be said about Jack Duckworth)
But the main reason I would love to see Jim back for a visit is the chemistry that has always been there between Lawson and Bev Callard as Jim and Liz McDonald. It's there with Simon Gregson as his son, as well. They all three just leap off the screen when they're in scenes together. It's not just familiarity that comes with acting together for a long time, either because it was evident even in the early days of the McDonald clan.
Jim and Liz were always a fiery couple. Jim had a quick temper but Liz had a volatile one as well. She was never cowed by him and stood up to him frequently, especially if she was defending one of her lads against their father's rages. It became too much, Liz started to look elsewhere, and they divorced but Jim is the love of Liz's life. He's edgy and a bit dangerous and she likes that in her men. I think that's why she seemed so suited to Tony Stewart. They are exciting and she knows they're probably going to let her down in the long run but she just can't resist.
Jim swept her off her feet as a teenager and they married when she got pregnant. She may have regretted that she was more or less a single parent because of his duties in the army but they had that passion that never really left and that's the passion she remembers when he comes around, even after years away. They fit together like two halves of a pair of scissors.
Will we see Jim return? There's always a possibility as long as Jim is alive and the producer and writers cook up a story. As much as Steve and Liz keep washing their hands of Jim and his monumental mistakes, Jim is still Steve's dad and Liz will always be in Jim's heart. She'll always be tempted even though she knows he's not good for her. Jim is Amy's granddad and they love each other. I think conversations between Jim and Amy as she is these days would be a joy to behold.
I'm definitely in the Yay camp. I'll tell you this and I'll tell you no more, Bring Back Big Jim!
Tvor (Twitter @tvordlj)
Like us on Facebook | Follow us on Twitter | Download our free App | Visit Corrie.net
Please read our advice for leaving comments on the Coronation Street Blog
All original work on the Coronation Street Blog is covered by a Creative Commons License
You might also like...
-
Monday 2nd November 2026 ROSS MAKES IT KNOWN WHO’S BOSS In the cell, Gary notices a gash on Marco’s arm. Marco plays it down but Gary’s sus...
-
Thurs 5th November 2026 KIT HITS BREAKING POINT An exhausted Kits ignores Lisa’s advice to go home but when a distressed woman in the waitin...
-
Here are the major storylines for the week ahead on Coronation Street, all wrapped up nicely. Monday 9 November to Wednesday 11 November, 20...
-
Wednesday 4th November 2026 CARLA CAN’T “INSURE” THE FUTURE OF THE FACTORY At Speed Daal, an angry Leanne confronts Idris and Brody and rev...
-
Tuesday 3rd November 2026 BRODY DAMPENS CARLA’S SPIRITS An intrigued Idris listens in as Carla confides in Lisa at the cafe that she will ha...
-
"It's like an episode of Prisoners' Wives," says Maria to Summer as they wait for their men in the visitors' room, w...
-
Good evening. I am back from India and I am here tonight but will be missing next Friday as there is no episode. I also feel an apology is...
-
On this episode of the podcast, we chat about what went on on the Street between the 2nd and the 5th November (Episodes #11,974 - #11,977). ...
-
If you lusted after Rosie Webster's sports car on Coronation Street then you might be interested to know that the PGO Cevennes car used...
-
Here are the major storylines for the week ahead on Coronation Street, all wrapped up nicely. Monday 2 November to Thursday 5 November, 2026...



